Turn-Taking in Human Communicative Interaction
Judith Holler
Turn-Taking in Human Communicative Interaction
Free
Description
Contents
Reviews

The core use of language is in face-to-face conversation. This is characterized by rapid turn-taking. This turn-taking poses a number central puzzles for the psychology of language. Consider, for example, that in large corpora the gap between turns is on the order of 100 to 300 ms, but the latencies involved in language production require minimally between 600ms (for a single word) or 1500 ms (for as simple sentence). This implies that participants in conversation are predicting the ends of the incoming turn and preparing in advance. But how is this done? What aspects of this prediction are done when? What happens when the prediction is wrong? What stops participants coming in too early? If the system is running on prediction, why is there consistently a mode of 100 to 300 ms in response time? The timing puzzle raises further puzzles: it seems that comprehension must run parallel with the preparation for production, but it has been presumed that there are strict cognitive limitations on more than one central process running at a time. How is this bottleneck overcome? Far from being 'easy' as some psychologists have suggested, conversation may be one of the most demanding cognitive tasks in our everyday lives. Further questions naturally arise: how do children learn to master this demanding task, and what is the developmental trajectory in this domain? Research shows that aspects of turn-taking such as its timing are remarkably stable across languages and cultures, but the word order of languages varies enormously. How then does prediction of the incoming turn work when the verb (often the informational nugget in a clause) is at the end? Conversely, how can production work fast enough in languages that have the verb at the beginning, thereby requiring early planning of the whole clause? What happens when one changes modality, as in sign languages -- with the loss of channel constraints is turn-taking much freer? And what about face-to-face communication amongst hearing individuals -- do gestures, gaze, and other body behaviors facilitate turn-taking? One can also ask the phylogenetic question: how did such a system evolve? There seem to be parallels (analogies) in duetting bird species, and in a variety of monkey species, but there is little evidence of anything like this among the great apes. All this constitutes a neglected set of problems at the heart of the psychology of language and of the language sciences. This research topic welcomes contributions from right across the board, for example from psycholinguists, developmental psychologists, students of dialogue and conversation analysis, linguists interested in the use of language, phoneticians, corpus analysts and comparative ethologists or psychologists. We welcome contributions of all sorts, for example original research papers, opinion pieces, and reviews of work in subfields that may not be fully understood in other subfields.

Language
English
ISBN
978-2-88919-825-2
Cover
Frontiers Copyright Statement
Turn-taking in human communicative interaction
Table of Contents
Editorial: Turn-Taking in Human Communicative Interaction
Foundations of Turn-Taking
Signals and Mechanisms for Prediction and Timing
Planning Next Turns in Conversation
Effects of Context and Function on Timing
Turn-Taking in Signed Languages
Development of Turn-Taking Skills
Funding
References
Timing in turn-taking and its implications for processing models of language
1. Introduction: Why Turn-Taking in Conversation is Important for the Psychology of Language
2. Turn-Taking as a System: Research from Conversation Analysis
3. An Alternative Signaling Approach
4. Challenges to the Standard Model
5. Statistical Studies of Corpora
5.1. Distribution of Gaps
5.2. Overlap
5.2.1. Method
5.2.2. Findings
6. Psycholinguistics
6.1. `Proto-Conversation' and Turn Taking in Human Development
6.2. Predictive Language Comprehension
6.3. Latencies in Language Production
6.4. Experimental Studies of Turn-Taking
6.5. The Core Psycholinguistic Puzzle
7. Models of Turn-taking
7.1. The Standard Model and Alternatives
7.2. Toward an Adequate Psycholinguistic Model of Turn Taking protect -- Cognitive Processes in the Responder1
8. Conclusion
Acknowledgment
References
The use of content and timing to predict turn transitions
Introduction
The Nature of Turn Transitions
The Processes Underlying Turn Transition
Managing Fluent Turn-Transition Requires Predicting Both Speech Content and Timing
Using Prediction-by-Simulation in Turn Transition
How does the Addressee Entrain Timing with the Speaker?
Preparing an Appropriate Response
How Addressees Take the Floor
Implications and Discussion
Acknowledgments
References
Social coordination in animal vocal interactions. Is there any evidence of turn-taking? The starling as an animal model
Introduction
The Human ``bases''
Coordination in Mammals and Birds' Vocal Interactions
Testing Turn Taking in an Animal Model: The Starling
Promoting or Not Turn-taking: Does the Social Situation Influence Temporal Features of Song?
Methods
Results
Individual adaptations to the social situation (Appendix 1 in Supplementary Material)
Isolation vs. field recordings (tab2Table 2 and Appendix 1 in Supplementary Material)
The importance of colony size (tab2Table 2 and fig2Figure 2)
Conclusion
Are There Temporal Regularities in Starling Vocal Interactions?
Methods
Results
Conclusion
Developmental Issues: How Do Young Birds Acquire an Appropriate Singing Style?
Normal Development
Disturbed Ontogeny: The Importance of Adults
Sensory and physical deprivation of experience with adults
Varying the type of contact with adults (Poirier et al., 2004)
Testing the impact of the adult-young ratio (Bertin et al., 2007)
Brain Mechanisms and Plasticity: The Processing of Song Categories and the Effect of Experience
Song Processing in Wild Caught Adults (George et al., 2004, 2008)
Conclusion
How Can Social Experience During Development Affect Brain Processing of Song Categories? (Cousillas et al., 2004, 2006; George et al., 2010)
Conclusion
Turn-taking as a Social Adaptation: An Evolutionary Process?
Methods
Results
Conclusion
Acknowledgments
Supplementary Material
References
Corrigendum: Social coordination in animal vocal interactions. Is there any evidence of turn-taking? The starling as an animal model
Anticipation in turn-taking: mechanisms and information sources
Introduction
Experiment 1
Materials and methods
Compliance with ethics guidelines
Participants
Stimulus collection
Design
Procedure
Results and discussion
Experiment 2
Materials and methods
Participants
Stimuli and design
Procedure
Results and discussion
Experiment 3
Materials and methods
Participants
Stimuli
Design
Procedure
Results and discussion
General discussion
Author contributions
Acknowledgment
References
Unaddressed participants' gaze in multi-person interaction: optimizing recipiency
Introduction
The timing of turns at talk
Third-person perspective eye-tracking studies on turn-taking
Methodological considerations
The present study: investigating eye movements and turns at talk in situ
Materials and methods
Participants and corpus
Laboratory set-up and technical equipment
Procedure
Analysis
Question-response sequences
Points of possible completion
Eye gaze
Statistical analysis
Results
Eye movements timed with respect to the end of turns
Eye movements timed with respect to the first possible completion
Unaddressed participants' eye movements and addressed participants' responses
Discussion
Unaddressed participants track current speakers
Unaddressed participants shift their gaze before turn ends
Unaddressed participants shift their gaze at possible turn completions
Optimizing recipiency
Conclusion
Acknowledgments
References
Action-projection in Japanese conversation: topic particles wa, mo, and tte for triggering categorization activities
Introduction
The Phenomenon
Japanese Conversational Grammar and Projectability
Previous Research on wa
Membership Categorization and Set Theory
Basic Categorization/Set-theoretic Actions Performed by Topic Particles
Wa for Triggering Anticipatory Completions and Preemptive Actions
Wa Used to Mobilize a ``Search Procedure'' for a Potential MCD when there is Ambiguous or Minimal Contextual Information
Concluding Comments
Acknowledgments
Supplementary Material
References
Word-by-word entrainment of speech rhythm during joint story building
Introduction
Methods
Participants, Apparatus, Materials
Procedure
Analysis
Results
General
Stability and Entrainment
Discussion
Acknowledgments
Supplementary Material
References
The effects of processing and sequence organization on the timing of turn taking: a corpus study
1. Introduction
2. Turn Taking in Interaction
3. Cognitive Planning and Comprehension
3.1. Turn Length
3.2. Frequency
3.3. Concreteness
3.4. Surprisal
3.5. Syntactic Complexity
4. Sequence Organization
4.1. Adjacency Pairs
4.2. Response Tokens
4.3. Laughter
5. Interactions between Processing and Sequence Organization
6. Materials and Methods
6.1. Calculating Floor Transfer Offset
6.2. Sequence Organization Data
6.3. Linking the Switchboard to Processing Measures
6.4. Random Forests
7. Results
7.1. Results for Measures of Processing
7.1.1. Turn Duration and Rate
7.1.2. Syntactic Complexity
7.1.3. Concreteness
7.2. Results for Measures of Sequence Organization
7.2.1. Initiating and Responding Actions
7.2.2. Backchannels
7.2.3. Positive Responses
7.3. Other Effects
8. Model Without Turn-Preserving Placeholders
9. Discussion
10. Conclusion
10.1. Human Search and Animal Research
10.2. Data Sharing
Author Contributions
Funding
Acknowledgements
Supplementary Material
References
Breathing for answering: the time course of response planning in conversation
Introduction
Materials and Methods
Material and Data Extraction
Coding and Measures
Data Extraction
Inbreath Annotation
Statistical Procedure
Results
Pre-Utterance Inbreaths and Answer Duration
Inbreath Characteristics and Answer Duration
Pre-Utterance Inbreaths and Answer Latency
Timing of Answerer's Inbreaths Relative to Question Ends
Discussion
Acknowledgments
References
The intersection of turn-taking and repair: the timing of other-initiations of repair in conversation
Introduction
The Timing of Turn-Taking
The Timing of Other-Initiations
The Practices of Other-Initiation
The Motivations for Delay Before Other-Initiations
The Current Investigation
Materials and Methods
Data
Identification of OIR
Open and Specific OIRs
Candidate Repair Solutions and Other-Corrections
OIRs in and After Next Position
Identification of Polar Questions
Measurements and Statistics
Results
The Timing of Other-Initiations of Repair
OIRs and Responses to Polar Questions
Open and Specific OIRs
Corrections and Non-Corrections
What do Speakers Use the Transition Spaces Before OIRs to Accomplish?
Searching for Late Recognition
Providing an Opportunity for Self-Initiated Repair
Producing Visual Signals
Discussion
The Motivations for and Consequences of Delay Before Other-Initiations of Repair
The Preferences for Self-Correction and Specificity
The Intersection of Turn-Taking and Repair
Acknowledgments
References
Expanded transition spaces: the case of Garrwa
Introduction
Rules, Gaps, and Lapses
Data and Methods
Results
Orienting to the Rules of Turn-Taking
Accounting for Long Silences and Expanded Transition Spaces
Silences After Selection of Next Speaker
Silences Before Self-Selection by Next Speaker
Extended Gaps in Conversation in Other Contexts
Discussion
Acknowledgments
References
Experience sharing, emotional reciprocity, and turn-taking
Sequentiality and Concurrency in Human Social Interaction
Hypothesis I: Experience Sharing is in Tension with the Sequential Framework of Turn-Taking
Hypothesis II: The Sequential Framework of Turn-Taking Serves Experience Sharing
Consequences for the Study of Turn-Taking
Acknowledgments
References
Turn-timing in signed conversations: coordinating stroke-to-stroke turn boundaries
Introduction
Materials and Methods
The NGT Interactive Corpus
Identification of Question–Answer Sequences
Movement Phase Coding
Phonetic Measures
Results
The Timing of Question–Answer Sequences
The Proportion of Overlapping and Delayed Turn Transitions
Launching Utterance Articulation in Sign
Turn-Timing in Dyadic vs. Triadic Interactions
Discussion
Acknowledgments
References
The management of turn transition in signed interaction through the lens of overlaps
Introduction
Research on Turn-Taking and Overlap in Sign Language
The Lexical Unit in Sign Language
The Turn and Turn Construction Unit in Conversation Analysis and Sign Language Research
Turn and TCU in Classic CA
Turn and TCU in Sign Language Research
The Turn-Taking Machinery in Signed Languages
Overlaps in Spoken and Signed Interaction
Method
Participants and Data
Procedure and Analysis
Annotation
Analysis
Sequential Environments of Overlapping Signing
Simultaneous Signing at Places of Possible Completion
Overlapping a Current Signer's New Unit at Places of Possible Completion
Overlapping a Current Signer's Dependent Unit at Places of Possible Completion
Simultaneous Signing after Places of Possible Completion
Simultaneous Signing before Places of Possible Completion
Overlapping a Current Signer's Last Item of a Unit
Overlapping a Current Signer's Potentially Last Item of a Unit
Simultaneous Signing Within Units
Discussion
The Orderliness of Overlaps in Multi-Party Signed Interaction
Gradual Turn Endings and Smooth Turn Transitions
Acknowledgments
References
Suspending the next turn as a form of repair initiation: evidence from Argentine Sign Language
Introduction
Argentine Sign Language (LSA)
Data and Method
Coding
Identification and Coding of Other-initiated Repair (OIR)
Coding and Transcription of ``Freeze-look'' Cases
Results
Question-answer Sequences
Fitted Responses to Questions
Non-fitted Response
Non-response due to non-attendance
Non-fitted response with signs of ``word search''
Non-fitted response: on-record repair
Freeze-look: A Notable Absence of Response
Pursuit Cases: From Implicit to Explicit OIR
Timing of ``Freeze-looks''
Conclusion
Acknowledgments
Supplementary Material
References
Early development of turn-taking in vocal interaction between mothers and infants
Introduction
Materials and Methods
Participants
Apparatus and Procedure
Acoustic Analysis
Selection of the Audio Samples
Software
Coding of Vocalizations and Pauses
Coding of Turn-Taking Sequences
Acoustic Measures
Inter-Coder Reliability
Statistics
Results
Vocal Production
Infant Vocalizations
Maternal Vocalizations
Vocalizations Involving Overlap
Latched Turns
Pauses
Within-Speaker Pauses
Switching Pauses
Turn-Taking Sequences
Discussion
Acknowledgments
References
Early developmental changes in the timing of turn-taking: a longitudinal study of mother–infant interaction
Introduction
Materials and Methods
Participants
Procedure and Design
Apparatus
Transcription
Results
Overlap
Gap
Reciprocity: Do Infants Equally Structure the Interaction?
General Discussion
Overlap
Gap
Reciprocity
Acknowledgments
References
Turn-taking: a case study of early gesture and word use in answering WHERE and WHICH questions
Introduction
Gestures in Young Children
Where and Which Questions
Materials and Methods
Coding
Results
Discussion
Recognizing and Retrieving Words
What Role does Articulation Play?
From Answering Questions to Turn-Taking and Interaction
Acknowledgments
References
The use of intonation for turn anticipation in observed conversations without visual signals as source of information
Introduction
Materials and Methods
Participants
Apparatus and Stimuli
Procedure
Data Analysis
Results
Gaze Latency
Distribution and Duration of Fixations
Occurrence Rate of Anticipatory and Random Gaze Shifts
Discussion
Children's and Adults' Cue Use for Turn Anticipation
Exceptional Turn Anticipation in 1-Year-Olds
Ecological Validity of Puppet Conversations
Conclusion
Acknowledgments
References
Dutch and English toddlers' use of linguistic cues in predicting upcoming turn transitions
Introduction
Experiment 1
Materials and Methods
Participants
Apparatus
Procedure
Audio Stimuli
Target utterances
Conversation design
Stimulus preparation
Stimulus pre-testing
Video Stimuli
Data Pre-Processing
Results
Pre-Analysis: Random Anticipatory Looking
Lexicosyntactic and Prosodic cues
Relative Weight of Lexicosyntactic and Prosodic Cues
Speaker Change or Speaker Continuation
Discussion
Experiment 2
Materials and Methods
Participants
Apparatus and Procedure
Materials
Target sentences
Conversation and video construction
Data Pre-Processing and Analysis
Results
Pre-Analysis: Random Anticipatory Looking
Lexicosyntactic and Prosodic Cues
Relative Weight of Lexicosyntactic and Prosodic Cues
Speaker Change or Speaker Continuation
Discussion
General Discussion
Lexicosyntactic vs. Prosodic Cues
Turn-Projection in a More Natural Context
Acknowledgments
References
Back Cover
The book hasn't received reviews yet.