Caribbean Constitutional Reform
This is the first book to be written on Caribbean constitutional theory. In the continuing discourse and emergent project of constitutional reform in the Commonwealth Caribbean, it examines the origins of the Independence Constitutions across the Commonwealth Caribbean and traces the region’s constitutional development from the time of the emancipation of slavery through to independence. At its core is the premise that constitutional reform must necessarily result in a redefining of West Indian political identity.
The theme throughout the book is the fact that the written constitutions of the Caribbean all have their origin in the British Parliament and the unwritten English constitution that has evolved over centuries. The existing constitutions were all the result of the collaborative efforts of the region’s political elite and British officials, with no participation from the West Indian people. The Crown is still claimed and the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council remains the final appellate court. In the result, political independence has simply meant that the countries of the Commonwealth Caribbean are independent subjects of the Crown rather than colonial subjects.
The book begins with the process of ‘lawful devolution of sovereignty’ and the origins of the sovereign states of the Commonwealth Caribbean and proceeds to address the theoretical issues of founding and amendability as well as such pressing issues about the relationship between a prime minister and a head of state in a parliamentary republic and electoral reform. An entire chapter is devoted to the Bill of Rights and addresses the fundamental rights and freedoms preserved in Caribbean Bills of Rights as well as the controversial and paradoxical Savings Clauses, which in and of themselves might justify the rewriting of the fundamental rights provisions of Commonwealth Caribbean Constitutions.
Caribbean Constitutional Reform offers a philosophical justification for the establishment of a Caribbean Supreme Court based on the idea of sovereignty and the right of a people to define themselves. This work makes the first definitive step to addressing these critical issues in Caribbean constitutional theory and sets the stage for a ‘new constitutional discourse’ shaped by a Caribbean court of final appeal.
- Constitutional Reform and Caribbean Political Identity
- The Question of Origin
- Towards a Constitutional Theory of Founding and Amendability
- Constitutional Self-binding
- Commonwealth Caribbean Constitutions
- The Amending Power
- Patriating the West Indian Independence Constitution
- Of West Indian Monarchies and Constitutional Absurdities
- Of Monarchies and Constitutional Republics
- Republicanism: A Theory of Freedom and Government
- Republicanism, Constitutionalism and Democracy
- The Modern British State: A Monarchical Republic
- Of Constitutional Monarchies and Parliamentary Republics
- American Republicanism
- American Republican Constitutionalism
- Commonwealth Caribbean Republican Constitutionalism
- Parliamentary or Presidential Republics?
- Constitutional Choice
- The President and Head of State
- The Legislature – Bicameral or Unicameral?
- Electoral Reform: ‘First-Past-the-Post’ or Proportional Representation?
- The Bill of Rights
- Fundamental Rights and Freedoms
- Writing and Reading the Texts
- Fundamental Rights and the Savings Clause
- The Special Savings Clause
- Reading Text and Polity: The Casefor a Caribbean Supreme Court
- The Judicial Opinion in the Republic of Law and Letters
- Marbury v. Madison
- The Cases
- Reading Precedent
- The Neville Lewis Case
- The CCJ and the Future of Capital Punishment in the Commonwealth Caribbean
- Select Bibliography